|
|
 | | From: | 3.14159 at consultant.com | | Subject: | Re: Armed Jews Week | | Date: | Tue, 28 Dec 2004 18:46:00 -0600 |
|
|
 | On 28 Dec 2004 16:29:37 -0800, "Deborah Sharavi"
wrote:
>>>>>3.14159@consultant.com wrote:
>>>>>>There are valid suspicions that his paternal grandparent may be
>>>>>>Jewish.
>
>>>>>There are none, outside propaganda fabrigated and disseminated by
>>>>>antisemites.
>
>>>3.14159@consultant.com wrote:
>>>>Nonsense. Toland states it in his bio of Hitler.
>
>>>Produce the cite.
>
>3.14159@consultant.com wrote:
>>Read the book.
>
>Have you read it?
More than once. have you?
>>>>>Even if true, having a Jewish paternal grandfather doesn't
>>>>>make anyone Jewish.
>
>>>>Not according to the Nazis.
>
>>>The facts remain that Shtler's father was illegitimate, was
>registered
>>>as such, and the father was not named. In April 1946 at Nuremberg,
>his
>>>adoring apostle Hans Frank stated that your mutual master's
>grandmother
>>>was a servant for the Frankenbergers, a Jewish family in Graz, and
>that
>>>the head of the household fathered her child. Despite the Gospel of
>the
>>>Fuhrer According to Frank, Jews had been driven out of Graz in the
>>>15thC and prohibited from returning until 1856, and no evidence
>exists
>>>of any Jewish mfaily named Frankenberger living there.
>
>>Funny, that...since there is factual evidence in the book that
>>contradicts your allegation.
>
>Have you read the book?
>
>>>The fact also remains that Nazis do not determine who is and who is
>not
>>>a Jew, much as you would prefer the contrary.
>
>>Incorrect. The people of the time with the guns decided for their
>>purposes and exterminated thousands.
>
>>Your disagreement with the facts notwithstanding.
>You haven't produced any.
>
>>>Now produce Toland's statement which you claim states the contrary.
>Can
>>>you?
>
>>Yes, read the book!
>
>Gee, what a surprise: three repetitions of "Read the book" in place of
>a cite. How typical.
I am not here to educate you. If you wish to remain ignorant that's
your problem.
|
|
|
